Commentary »

Discuss     Bury  Add To 
Mr Hayward spoke about the pressures the industry was under as it struggled to keep up with ever rising demand from the emerging economies. Such was the "supply challenge" companies would have to explore more and more difficult environments from which to gain oil - the lifeblood of markets around the world. A 40pc increase in demand would create the need for 15m barrels per day (bpd) increased production over the next two decades.

Mr Hayward was excited about the future. Iraq was developing as a major oil producer and new methods of extracting oil from tar sands across North America revealed that the business was keeping pace with demand. There was a third element to Mr Hayward's narrative - deep drilling in the Gulf of Mexico.

That is the backdrop to the catastrophic rig collapse off the coast of Louisiana two weeks ago. Eleven people were killed and estimates of how many barrels are leaking into the sea vary from 5,000 to 25,000 a day. Such is the depth of the drilling site - 4,500ft - that no one really knows what is going on down there.

As BP, alongside Transocean, struggles to contain the spiralling costs of the clean-up operation following the explosion and destruction of the $500m (£327m) Deepwater Horizon rig, it is becoming clear that the whole of the oil industry is holding its breath.

Until now, the oil companies have been greatly advantaged by a relatively benign environment surrounding exploring in the oil-rich shelf off Louisiana and Florida. Local politicians and regulators welcomed the employment and wealth the industry bought. Even the shrimp fishers who are now launching multi-million dollar class actions against BP and Transocean often doubled as oil workers.

That is all now changing. Florida governor, Charlie Crist, said last week that he believed there should be clampdown on drilling in the Gulf. When President Barack Obama arrives in the area today he may well go further than the temporary suspension of new drilling already announced. Just as with the banks, the President is up for a fight with BP - "they must pick up all the costs" - ahead of the crucial mid-term elections.

Reading the long list of oil-spill incidents on the Minerals Management Service safety register it is clear that Deepwater Horizon had previous. All quite minor, but revealing, nevertheless, that working in deep water in an area prone to hurricanes engenders enormous risk.

In Febuary 2002, 103 barrels leaked; in June 2003, 994 barrels of oil leaked after a pipe disconnected in bad weather; in August the same year, 74 barrels leaked, three days later 138 barrels leaked after "equipment failure"; November 22 and 23 2005, 212 barrels leaked following "equipment failure and human error". Interestingly, the last incident involved problems with a cement plug on the well, an issue that has been raised this time as a possible cause of the accident.

This is now not just a question limited to its impact on BP - one of Britain's most successful companies, but to the whole of the sector.

An analyst note from Goldman Sachs on the possible impact sums it up:

"The tide of oil from the collapsed Horizon deepwater drilling platform threatens to disrupt shipping in the US Gulf of Mexico and inflict extensive environmental damage along the Gulf Coast," it said.

"While the most substantial impact of the oil spill will likely be environmental and the impact it might have on future legislation around offshore drilling, the potential disruption of oil tanker traffic in the Gulf is already having an impact on oil prices."

Mr Hayward appeared to enjoy Davos - and his message was positive. Now, as he contemplates the growing disaster of the spill in the Gulf of Mexico this weekend, he cannot be so sure.

Deep breath for PRU
Tidjane Thiam, the chief executive of Prudential, is going to need every ounce of his persuasive muscle when it comes to the publication of the prospectus for the insurance giant's $35bn takeover of AIA this week.

With increasingly loud muttering that the price is simply too high for a mature business operating out of Asia (a market that contains as many pitfalls as it does opportunities) Mr Thiam needs to set out a compelling case for why this is the right move.

That case will come under three headings. Firstly, strategy - is this the right direction for a UK business looking to expand and increase investor return? Second, price. Is $35bn simply too high? And thirdly, execution. Is the management of Prudential up to the task of amalgamating two large business across 13 countries involving hundreds of thousands of agents?

On point one, as I have written before, the strategy is the right one. Prudential is a global player and to have sat back and watched AIA list in Hong Kong and then come hunting for the bits of the Prudential it most liked was not a scenario with much attraction.

Point three is also likely to be answered in the affirmative. Barry Stowe, the CEO of Prudential's Asia business, knows AIA well (he used to work there) and has many years of experience. As one senior figure close to the deal put it to me, the insurance business "is actually pretty simple" and agents can move easily.

It is on point two that Mr Thiam will have to do most work. Investors who will expected to take up the $21bn rights issue needed to finance the deal are concerned that the high price for AIA is more to do with parent company AIG's desire to pay back to the American government the billions of dollars of bail-out money it received than with the actual value of the business.

Prudential sources insist that there will be plenty of "granular detail" about the value of AIA, "proving" the price and showing investor return over a three-year horizon. More importantly, for many investors, as we reveal today, there is also likely to be some red meat over the next year: the $5bn UK business and multi-billion dollar businesses in India and China are likely to see the "For Sale" sign raised.

If you want to know what Prudential will look like in five years' time, take a look at Standard Chartered: headquartered in the UK, with nearly all its business overseas. That, it appears, is Mr Thiam's plan.

Who Voted for this Scoop

Comments

No one has commented on this article yet.

Log in to comment or register here.